⚠️ The Pattern
Premium increases — especially after your first claim — are one of the most common complaints on SA pet insurance forums. The advertised R80-R120/month starting price is for a young, healthy pet. Your actual premium will almost certainly be higher, and it will climb over time.
What Real Owners Are Reporting
Dotsure — 47% Increase After First Claim
A Hellopeter reviewer (2025-2026) reported that their Dotsure premium jumped by nearly half — after years of paying premiums without claiming. The reviewer stated: "Dotsure has been great in claims in my time with them. There were many years that I did not claim and then my pet got sick" — and then the massive increase hit. This pattern of loyalty-penalty pricing is not unique to Dotsure.
OUTsurance — Premium Creep
On Reddit's r/askSouthAfrica, a user paying R510 and R506 for two dogs on OUTsurance reported premiums creeping up over time, with no significant change in cover level. Another thread showed an older OUTsurance policy at ~R150/cat — suggesting significant inflation in newer policies.
Oneplan — R700/month for Two Dogs
A Hellopeter reviewer (January 2026) was paying approximately R700/month for two dogs on Oneplan, and discovered that dental benefits had been reclassified between cover categories with a lower cap — effectively reducing coverage while premiums presumably stayed the same or increased.
Why Are Premiums Going Up?
- Vet costs are rising: SA vet practices face R300k-R450k/month in operating costs and imported equipment. As the cost of care goes up, insurers pay more per claim, and pass that on.
- Your pet is aging: Most insurers price-lock at signup based on your pet's age. As your pet gets older, your risk category changes, and premiums adjust upward.
- Post-claim re-rating: Some insurers increase premiums after you file a claim, even if the claim was paid. This is standard practice in insurance, but it catches pet owners off guard.
- Industry-wide adjustments: Dotsure's 47% increase may reflect broader industry repricing, not just your individual risk profile.
What You Can Do About It
1. Don't Assume Loyalty Is Rewarded
Pet insurance in SA works on a month-to-month model. There's no penalty for switching (except new waiting periods). If your premium jumps significantly, shop around.
2. Compare Before You Switch
Use our side-by-side comparison to see what other insurers offer at your price point. But remember: switching means new waiting periods (30 days for illness, up to 12 months for hereditary conditions). Weigh the saving against the coverage gap.
3. Ask Your Insurer for a Reason
Request a written explanation for the increase. Some insurers will adjust if you push back, especially if you have a clean claims history.
4. Adjust Your Cover Level
If your premium is climbing faster than you can afford, consider dropping from Comprehensive to Accident + Illness, or increasing your excess. The premium calculator shows the range for each cover tier.
The Bottom Line
Premium increases are a feature, not a bug, of SA pet insurance. The advertised starting prices are for ideal customers only — young, healthy pets with no claims history. Budget for your premium to increase 10-30% annually and be ready to shop around when it does.
The best defence is annual comparison shopping. When your renewal comes around, check whether a competitor offers similar cover for less — factoring in any new waiting periods you'd face by switching.
→ Back to the insurance guide · Compare all SA insurers · Estimate your premium